Hey Marcia, thanks for the feedback. The soaps are what give the boxes their smell. If the boxes smell like three different scents that would be because each box has a different scented soap inside. I am not exactly sure how it would be possible for them all to smell the same but be different even when the boxes retained the scents. This is the first time we've ever had this type of feedback. Maybe try using them one at a time in the shower as water usually helps reveal a fresh layer and this layer should smell just like it should. Only thing I can think of is maybe from them being in the same package the scents may have mixed and this possibly could have caused a change in scent. However; like I have said this usually doesn't happen (we have never heard of it happening) and I think just using them should fix the issue. Please let me know if this doesn't fix the issue and we'd be glad to make things right!